Mystery Island: Play for Keeps Hallmark Movie, Cast

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps Hallmark Movie, Cast, Released date, Story 2025

The Hallmark Movie Mystery Island: Play for Keeps will premiere on June 5, 2025.

The Story of Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

Mystery Island is a work retreat for a company. One of the guests is Emilia’s old fiancé. When they see each other again, old feelings come back, and things get tense. Then, someone is found dead, and people start blaming each other.

The Cast of Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

1 Charlie Weber as Jason Trent

Charlie Weber is a popular American actor and Model who works predominantly in Hollywood movies and television series. He is well known for his acting performances in Hollywood television series such as How to Get Away with Murder and Underemployed.

Considering his innocent face and charming smile Hallmark Channel hired him for Christmas Bedtime Stories, which was released during Christmas time in 2022. Charlie Weber coming with another Hallmark Movie Mystery Island in 2023 with popular actress Elizabeth Henstridge. Read Full Bio

2 Elizabeth Henstridge as Dr. Emilia Priestly

Elizabeth Frances Henstridge is an English actress, director, and model. She is well-known for her role as Jemma Simmons in the superhero drama series Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Hallmark Channel hired Henstridge for a movie Christmas at the Plaza in 2019. Which was her first Hallmark movie, where she worked with a popular Hallmark actor Ryan Paevey.

Her role as Jessica Cooper was praised by audiences. The movie is about Jessica, an archival historian, who creates an exhibition about the history of Christmas at The Plaza Hotel.

In 2023, she  appeared in the Hallmark Mystery movie My Island along with famous actor Charlie Weber. Read Full Bio

3 Nisha Aaliya as Patricia Collacello

Nisha Aaliya is a British actress, born in Holland, Netherlands. She began her acting career in 2018 and is still going strong.

Nisha is best known for her role as Raava Rhodey Skrull in the 2023 TV mini-series Secret Invasion, as Farah the stewardess in the 2024 series Rivals, and as Nimrat Kaur in the 2025 show Virdee. Read Full Bio

4 Victoria Bolt as Viveca Bentley

5 Suanne Braun as Morgan Bennett

Where to Watch Hallmark Movie Mystery Island: Play for Keeps?

Viewers can watch Mystery Island: Play for Keeps on Saturday, June 5, 2025, at 7 p.m. ET/PT on the Hallmark Channel.

Movie Highlights

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps Hallmark Movie, Cast, Released date, Story 2025