Mystery Island: House Rules Hallmark Movie, Cast

Mystery Island: House Rules Hallmark Movie, Cast, Released date, Story 2025

The Hallmark movie Mystery Island: House Rules will premiere on  September 14, 2025

The Story of Mystery Island: House Rules

After the success of Mystery Island, there are plans to make it bigger. The Island team meets the Mystery Mountain team for a fun murder game, but things turn serious when someone is really murdered in front of everyone.

The Cast of Mystery Island: House Rules

1 Elizabeth Henstridge as Dr. Emilia Priestly

Elizabeth Frances Henstridge is an English actress, director, and model. She is well-known for her role as Jemma Simmons in the superhero drama series Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

Hallmark Channel hired Henstridge for a movie Christmas at the Plaza in 2019. Which was her first Hallmark movie, where she worked with a popular Hallmark actor Ryan Paevey.

Her role as Jessica Cooper was praised by audiences. The movie is about Jessica, an archival historian, who creates an exhibition about the history of Christmas at The Plaza Hotel.

In 2023, she  appeared in the Hallmark Mystery movie My Island along with famous actor Charlie Weber. Read Full Bio

2 Charlie Weber as Jason Trent

Charlie Weber is a popular American actor and Model who works predominantly in Hollywood movies and television series. He is well known for his acting performances in Hollywood television series such as How to Get Away with Murder and Underemployed.

Considering his innocent face and charming smile Hallmark Channel hired him for Christmas Bedtime Stories, which was released during Christmas time in 2022. Charlie Weber coming with another Hallmark Movie Mystery Island in 2023 with popular actress Elizabeth Henstridge. Read Full Bio

3 Suanne Braun as Morgan Bennett

Suanne Braun is an actress and director, best known for her role as Katrina in the TV series The Big Time (1991–1993), as Elaine in the TV movie A Royal Winter, and as Mrs. Donatelli in the Netflix film The Princess Switch 3: Romancing the Star.

Actress Suanne Braun was born on February 29, 1968, in South Africa.  At present she is 57 years old, about her family, there is no specific information on social media. Read Full Bio

4 Sophie Meister as Inga Sorenson

Sophie Meister is a talented actress, writer, and producer who is 43 years old as of 2025. She was born on November 1, 1981, in Freital, which was then part of the German Democratic Republic.

Over the years, Sophie has built a name for herself with her powerful performances. She first caught attention in 2010 with the short film Awakening, where she played the role of Silver.

Later, in 2017, she impressed audiences again as Jamie in the short film Last Call. Most recently, in 2023, she took on the role of Mia in Five to One, further proving her talent and versatility. Read Full Bio

5 Francisco Labbe as Carlos Del Fuego

Francisco Labbe, birth name is Francisco Javier Labbe Mena, is an American actor and director. He became well known for his roles in popular projects playing Francisco in the film Children of Men, Rafael Portillo in the series McMafia, David Agnoli in Halo, and Javier Rubio in Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan.

In 2023, he joined the Hallmark family with the movie Mystery Island, where he played Carlos Del Fuego alongside Elizabeth Henstridge and Charlie Weber. Read Full Bio

6 Donald Sage Mackay as Dr. Stanley Williams

Where to Watch Hallmark Movie Mystery Island: House Rules?

Viewers can watch Mystery Island: House Rules  on Sunday, September 14, 2025, at 8 p.m. ET/PT on the Hallmark Channel.

Movie Highlights

Mystery Island: House Rules Hallmark Movie, Cast, Released date, Story 2025